BROKEN DOLLS by Ally Malinenko

This review first appeared in Booklist on September 1, 2025.

Kaye is struggling with the death of her beloved grandfather, her grief manifesting in unexpected ways: compulsive counting and selective mutism. These habits help soothe her anxious mind but make it difficult to express her growing melancholy to a family that already seems to have moved on. It’s a lot for any young person to handle, and it threatens to make this summer—spent helping renovate Grampa’s old house—emotionally overwhelming. And then the dolls arrive. The first one is creepy enough—a porcelain poppet that looks eerily like her younger sister, Holly—but before long, the house is overrun with grotesque, frightening figures. Most disturbingly, the dolls seem alive; Kaye sees them moving around at night and hears them whispering in the dark. Soon, it becomes clear that these twisted toys have sinister schemes in mind for Holly—and that Kaye must reckon with her sorrow in order to save her sister’s life. This thoughtful, profoundly compassionate exploration of anxiety and grief also serves up some serious scares. Malinenko (This Appearing House, 2022) portrays Kaye’s emotional journey in a way that feels real, relatable, and resonant, without ever sacrificing the story’s suspense. A perfect pick for fans of Katherine Arden’s Small Spaces (2018) and Lindsay Currie’s What Lives in the Woods (2021).

LET’S SPLIT UP by Bill Wood

This review first appeared in Booklist on September 1, 2025.

When the mutilated bodies of two popular students turn up inside an ancient, decrepit mansion on the outskirts of Sanera, California, rumors spread like wildfire—chief among them that the gruesome deed was the work of the malevolent spirit said to haunt the historic house. Friends Amber, Cam, and Jonesy are particularly shaken by the news of their murdered classmates. With encouragement from Buffy—the new girl in town, eager to make a good impression—they set out to unravel the mystery. Whether the culprit is a supernatural slayer or a living, breathing killer, the bodies begin to pile up. And when the intrepid friends become targets themselves, they must come together as a group . . . or die. Debut author Wood wears his influences on his bloody sleeves, delivering a fast-paced homage to the slasher genre, brimming with knowing winks and genuine thrills. While it treads familiar ground, Wood’s enthusiasm for the material is evident and infectious, making for a lively read. Readers who enjoy horror with a healthy dose of playful self-awareness will have a great time solving mysteries with these meddling kids.

THE SILENCED by Diana Rodriguez Wallach

This review first appeared in Booklist on September 1, 2025.

Hazel Perez thinks the worst part of her latest school project is being grouped with her ex–best friend, Becca. But then a research trip to their chosen subject—the long-abandoned Oakwell Farms School for Girls—ends with Hazel falling through a roof. She wakes up in the hospital with a broken arm, a concussion, and a ghostly hitchhiker. An angry, vengeful spirit has latched onto her, and it’s threatening to take over. Desperate to break free, Hazel starts digging into the Farm’s past, soon uncovering decades of unspeakable abuse by the men who ran the place unchecked. With help from family, renewed friendships, and budding romance, Hazel works to expose the Farm’s cruel history, hoping to restore the voices of silenced women and bring peace to the restless spirits that were left behind. Blending supernatural suspense with harrowing historical fact, Wallach shines a scathing spotlight on the deeply disturbing troubled-teen industry through a haunting tale of justice and grief, where the true terror lies not in the ghosts but in the atrocities that created them. 

SONGS FOR GHOSTS by Clara Kumagai

This review first appeared in Booklist on August 1, 2025.

For Adam, life feels like a series of struggles. At home, tensions with his distant father and wary stepmother are coming to a head. At school, with college looming, there’s pressure to decide his future—particularly whether he wants to pursue music professionally, which he enjoys but doesn’t feel especially passionate about. Emotionally, he feels heartbroken and adrift, unsure if he truly belongs anywhere. Then he finds a kindred spirit in a diary written a century ago by a passionate, independent young woman whose experiences seem to mirror his own. But she also writes about ghosts that come to her in the night, seeking solace. Adam assumes this is mere metaphor—until he’s suddenly haunted by the woman’s own restless, sullen spirit. Hoping to give her peace, Adam embarks on a journey to unravel not only the mysteries of a tangled past but also those of his own tumultuous present. Lyrical and haunting, Kumagai’s ghostly tale of love and identity is a testament to the healing power of story and its capacity to bridge divides between cultures and generations. Based on Giacomo Puccini’s Madama Butterfly, this is an act of reclamation, telling the story from the perspective of the opera’s most marginalized character and illuminating often overlooked aspects of Japanese life in the early twentieth century. A beautiful and necessary work.

THE PUMPKIN PRINCESS AND THE BURIED CASTLE by Steven Banbury

This review first appeared in Booklist on August 1, 2025.

Peculiar things have been happening to Eve ever since the events of the Forever Night transpired nearly a year ago—when, thanks to the undead denizens of Hallowell Valley, her life changed forever. Or was it her death? The Pumpkin Princess isn’t quite sure anymore. Now she’s dealing with some weird and magical changes: breathing fire like her adoptive father, the Pumpkin King; drifting through walls like her ghostly neighbors; and, apparently, being the only one who can see the mysterious shadow with glowing green eyes lurking around town. Then, on All Hallows’ Eve, the shady specter approaches her, presenting her with a tempting but impossible choice—one that comes with catastrophic consequences no matter what she decides. In the disastrous aftermath, Eve must steadfastly step into her role as princess and steward to save not only the land of the undead but also the world of the living. In this sequel to The Pumpkin Princess and the Forever Night (2024), Banbury significantly expands his enchanting world with fresh faces, new dangers, and remarkable revelations. While the numerous additions make the plot feel a little convoluted at times, they also offer ample opportunities for meaningful character growth, particularly among the supporting cast, which truly gets to shine in this bewitching tale of friendship, family, and fairness. Another fantastic fall fable.

THE DEVIL’S IN THE DANCERS by Catherine Yu

This review first appeared in Booklist on July 1, 2025.

Mars Chang has just landed a summer scholarship at the Allegra Academy, a prestigious ballet institution that could open many distinguished doors for the young, ambitious dancer. Once there, however, she’s met with disdain due to her modest background, quickly learning that at this esteemed institution, class and legacy matter more than talent and skill. But she presses on, dancing through the derision gracefully enough to catch the attention of the school’s venal, venerated founder. Mars is soon thrust into a corrupt choreography, perilously pirouetting around the academy’s darker deeds. When these nefarious affairs put the life of her budding crush in danger, Mars must decide whether her passions and aspirations are worth sacrificing her conscience and sense of self. Yu’s intense ballet drama is as much a critique of class divisions as it is an adolescent melodrama of ambition and moral conflict, and the feints and flourishes will keep readers riveted. Present alongside other visceral stagings of elitism and entitlement, such as A. K. Small’s Bright Burning Stars (2019) and Erica Ridley’s The Protégée (2025).

WELCOME TO THE GHOST SHOW by J.W. Ocker

This review first appeared in Booklist on July 1, 2025.

Hazel “Zel” Gold longs to see ghosts. Along with her friends and fellow aficionados of the weird, Theo and Lucien, she forms the Creepy Club, a group dedicated to exploring the lurid and eerie corners of their small Maryland town in search of anything remotely paranormal. One day, ominous posters appear around town, heralding the arrival of the Ghost Show, a mysterious traveling attraction that claims to feature real ghosts. The Creepy Club jumps at the chance to finally witness some supernatural spectacle, only to find the show spearheaded by the imposing and enigmatic Everest Nocturama Mancer, a self-professed ghost catcher who plans to exploit the town’s tragic, haunted history for his own ghastly purposes. It’s up to Zel and her friends to save not only their bereaved community but also the suffering spirits ensnared in Mancer’s grasp. Ocker conjures a magnificently macabre and gleefully grotesque tale that’s as much a celebration of the odd and the peculiar as it is a thoughtful and affecting meditation on mortality, grief, and the painful process of letting go.

PREDATORY NATURES by Amy Goldsmith

This review first appeared in Booklist on June 1, 2025.

After a series of personal tragedies leaves her friendless and aimless, Lara Williams finds herself uprooted, wanting nothing more than to escape the mess that’s become her life. So when she gets the chance to work aboard the Banebury, a luxury train traveling through the lush European countryside, she jumps at the opportunity, determined to at least run away in style. Not even the unexpected presence of an old, maybe-sort-of flame among her fellow crew members can dampen her spirits. But shortly into the voyage, a mysterious set of siblings board the Banebury, bringing two carriages overflowing with strange, beautiful flora—and an ancient, ominous force waiting to take root. Inspired by Welsh mythology and combining elements of folk horror and dark academia, Goldsmith cultivates a fierce, frightening fantasy that draws powerful parallels between folkloric tragedy and the grim mundanity of modern misogyny. Predatory Natures grafts itself into the flourishing genre of botanical horror, joining the ranks of Krystal Sutherland’s House of Hollow (2021) and Andrea Hannah’s Where Darkness Blooms (2023).

GLOAM by Jack Mackay

This review first appeared in Booklist on June 1, 2025.

After her mother’s untimely passing, Gwen and her siblings, along with Henry, their stepfather, move into their late grandmother’s house—known simply as “The House”—on the small, gray, aptly named island of Gloam. There they meet the ethereal Esme, a local babysitter whose demeanor and general attitude toward the bereaved family seems just a tad too perfect to be genuine, earning Gwen’s immediate mistrust. Sure enough, Esme’s mere presence heralds the arrival of a sinister, creeping darkness—one that threatens to consume not only the old, mysterious house itself but Gwen and her family as well. Now it’s up to Gwen to unlock the house’s secrets and banish the stirring nightmares within. Featuring a bold and tenacious protagonist, a supporting cast of instantly endearing characters, and a veritable phantasmagoria of ghastly ghouls, debut author Mackay delivers a classic tale of children’s horror that’s as chilling as it is heartfelt. Exploring themes of grief, resilience, and kinship, Gloam earns its spot on the shelf alongside the likes of Jonathan Auxier’s The Night Gardener (2014) and Kenneth Oppel’s The Nest (2015).

STITCH by Pádraig Kenny

This review first appeared in Booklist on June 1, 2025.

Stitch leads a simple life in the castle at the edge of the forest. Every morning, he wakes up and makes a mark on the wall, one for every day since he first awoke: 585 days ago as of the story’s start. He feeds his pet mouse. He visits his friend Henry, locked inside a cage, and they chat. He goes out to the garden and dreams of exploring the world. And he checks on the Professor to see if he’s still asleep. This routine is interrupted by the arrival of the Professor’s nephew, who is accompanied by an assistant, Alice, as well as a barrage of bad news—and life in the castle will never again be the same. Kenny (The Monsters of Rookhaven, 2021) takes apart the original Frankenstein tale and sews the pieces back into an uplifting fable that’s bursting at the seams with heart and optimism. Stitch explores themes of friendship, prejudice, and morality through the eyes of a large-hearted protagonist who never fails to approach it all with empathy and kindness.