This review first appeared in Booklist on August 1, 2025.

Peculiar things have been happening to Eve ever since the events of the Forever Night transpired nearly a year ago—when, thanks to the undead denizens of Hallowell Valley, her life changed forever. Or was it her death? The Pumpkin Princess isn’t quite sure anymore. Now she’s dealing with some weird and magical changes: breathing fire like her adoptive father, the Pumpkin King; drifting through walls like her ghostly neighbors; and, apparently, being the only one who can see the mysterious shadow with glowing green eyes lurking around town. Then, on All Hallows’ Eve, the shady specter approaches her, presenting her with a tempting but impossible choice—one that comes with catastrophic consequences no matter what she decides. In the disastrous aftermath, Eve must steadfastly step into her role as princess and steward to save not only the land of the undead but also the world of the living. In this sequel to The Pumpkin Princess and the Forever Night (2024), Banbury significantly expands his enchanting world with fresh faces, new dangers, and remarkable revelations. While the numerous additions make the plot feel a little convoluted at times, they also offer ample opportunities for meaningful character growth, particularly among the supporting cast, which truly gets to shine in this bewitching tale of friendship, family, and fairness. Another fantastic fall fable.